Objective: The purposes of this study are to describe from narratives the experiences of independent midwives who sustained relationships with clients even after a midwifery accident, and to clarify the feelings of midwives regarding their relationship with the client resulting from a midwifery accident and the process of coming to terms with the accident.
Participants and methods: A life story research design was used to investigate four independent midwives. Data were collected by asking participants details of midwifery accidents.
Results: The present study described the life stories of Participant A, who still struggles to completely come to terms with the midwifery accident; Participant B, who decided to live with the burden of her negligence; Participant C, who continues to question the meaning of the accident while recognizing her own over-optimism and weaknesses; and Participant D, who immediately faced up to and came to terms with the entire situation after the accident.
Discussion: The independent midwives, cognizant of sustaining the relationship with the client even post-accident, faced the fact that despite their best efforts, the accidents were attributable to overly optimistic midwifery diagnoses and management. All four midwives went through a different process of acceptance, reaching their own understanding of the adverse event. For the midwives, the shock of being at fault in a midwifery accident constitutes what can be described as a critical situation, and sustaining the relationship with the client and her husband, and receiving the support of individuals connected with the accident were instrumental in getting back on their feet. The findings point to the following implications for dealing with the aftermath of a midwifery accident: along with the solidifying of institutional support measures, the necessity to produce guidelines focusing in particular on early response under the assumption that accidents can and do happen.
View full abstract