The current stand density control diagram (SDCD) for private and public Sugi (
Cryptomeria japonica) man-made forests were created between FY1978 and 1980. Several studies have suggested need for revising the current SDCD due to existence of high-density stands with the relative yield index (
Ry) exceeding 1.0 and the tendency for total stem volume to be underestimated. In this study, SDCD for seven regions was revised using new data collected since 2003. First, a new maximum density curve, common to private and public Sugi forests across Japan was developed, resulting in a gentler slope than the current version, closer to -3/2. The current SDCD underestimates both the stand volume and mean diameter at breast height (DBH), but the revised version is able to estimate these values without bias. However, variability was high, with only 50–70% of the data achieving an estimate of stand volume with an error margin of less than 20%, depending on the region. This is likely due to the increasing diversification of management history and stand structure resulting from the thinning age, thinning rate and the aging of the stands. In order to improve estimation accuracy, it is necessary to produce more detailed regional classifications, such as at the prefectural level. Unlike the current SDCD,
Ry calculated in the revised version can be approximated by a nearly single curve for each region in relation to relative spacing (
Sr), making it easier to interpret the relationship between
Ry and
Sr. In conclusion, the revised SDCD could estimate total stem volume more accurately than current version, based on the top height and stand density. This improved reliability of using the SDCD as the basis for creating the yield table.
View full abstract